Dec. 18th, 2011

worldoflucky: (Default)
Earlier today I posted this to my facebook/google+ accounts. I just was thinking today bout religion and about people burning in hell (I had just read an article of a preacher praising the fact that Christopher Hitchens was burning in hell). So I came up with the following.

Is it fair to cast someone out for eternity for the mistakes of a single lifetime, even a long lifetime? Does 80 years of sinning really deserve eternity of torment? Even the most vile person doesn't deserve to burn in hell for billions of years.


It seems as the eons stretch out, that a truly just God would give an option to be let out for good behavior, but then that is saying that god is just and benevolent. If he isn't, he would keep someone suffering forever.

Take a long life of 80 years and divide it by 14 billion years (the current believed age of this universe), A person only lives 0.00000000571429 of the time the universe existed. To convert that to percentages its still only 0.000000571429% lifespan of the universe. 

Now that number is hard to understand so let me break it down into something we can understand in lay terms. If a person lives 80 years. That percentage represents roughly 14.4 seconds. That means if the lifespan of the universe is 80 years, we are judged on what we do for 14.4 seconds.

That doesn't seem fair or just. Perhaps this means if God is fair and just that there is reincarnation and we get more than one chance. If he doesn't give you more than one, and he really exists, then he isn't as benevolent as you think. 

edit:
I
 had a friend asked me if I felt this way now that it has come out that Kim Jong Il is gone and how I felt about that. I figured I would put my response here as well:

I do. I honestly think this goes for Hitler as well. Hitler was evil, but people are shaped by their birth issues, life experiences, by mental illness and by disease (syphilis in Hitler's case). A mentally healthy person doesn't do those acts. 

Even Hitler, Pol Pot, Dahmer or Gacy don't deserve an eternity. If the whole heaven or hell thing is true, either they should only be punished after a certain amount of time (say a thousand years for every life they took - that number is of course arbitrary) or they should be judged over the course of several life times. 

If someone makes the same mistakes (or similar ones) over the course of time then maybe they do deserve it. After all God supposedly will come and judge the living and the dead. That means according to Christian theology no one is in hell yet as judgment happens at the same time for everyone. I could be more understanding if people were reborn constantly until that time and they were judged overall.

Then again I never fit in with Catholic theology well, always felt there might be reincarnation.

That was just my response. I
 wonder if I should have done this as a video blog.

Profile

worldoflucky: (Default)
World of Lucky

May 2017

S M T W T F S
 1234 56
7 8910111213
14151617181920
212223 24252627
28293031   

Most Popular Tags

Page Summary

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 16th, 2025 03:36 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios